The current leftie line on the Ezra Levant/Mark Steyn versus Human Rights Commissions and the power of Islam controversy goes roughly as follows.
- Right wingers support limitations on the right of Human Rights Commissions to suppress speech.
- Right wingers are evil people, as we all know. (Conservative liberals in the style of George Jonas must be conflated with national socialists to make this desperate analogy work).
- Therefore the attempt by Keith Martin, MP, to rein in the Canadian Human Rights Commission is itself unwarranted and possibly evil.
Nothing in Joan Bryden’s piece (linked above) spoke of the suppression of free speech, for the sake of Islam.
Nothing about the establishment of religion in a secular state.
Nothing about the unfairness that gives the HRCs every procedural, evidentiary, and cost-imposing advantage.
Nothing about the proper role, if any, of Human Rights Commissions in a liberal democratic society. Just: “Some racialists support Keith Martin.” I quote:
“Victoria MP Keith Martin was praised Friday on stormfront.org, a website that proudly displays the logo “White pride world wide” and links to radio addresses by former Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke.
“Martin earned the dubious distinction after giving notice that he plans to introduce a private member’s motion calling on the government to repeal Section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act.
“The controversial section prohibits electronic communication of anything deemed “likely to expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt.” It is at the heart of investigations by human rights tribunals into complaints against former Western Standard publisher Ezra Levant and Maclean’s magazine for publishing material some Muslim groups found offensive.
“The cases of Levant and Maclean’s writer Mark Steyn have sparked much furious debate, nowhere more so than among right-wing bloggers.”
It reminds me of the time I was debating capital punishment with a then NDP Member of Parliament, Simon de Jong (a very decent chap and wrong about a huge number of things).
- They hang people in South Africa.
- We oppose apartheid in South Africa.
- Therefore capital punishment is morally wrong.
Are the Left really that stupid? Do they think we ought to believe them? Do they believe this stuff themselves?
Joan, I know you have to write stuff for a living every day, but you have got yourself on the wrong side of this transcendently important issue. The Human Rights Commission issue is not about striking the right cocktail party attitudes, it is about your right not wear a hijab and also to express rude thoughts, in private and public, about right wingers (you can fill in the blank for the appropriate group whose thoughts, feelings and attitudes you wish to disparage), without living in fear.
As the replicant Combat Team Leader, Roy Batty, said at the end of Blade Runner:
Now you know what it’s like to be a slave: always living in fear.
I do not want to live that way, and the right wingers’ fight against HRCs, as you label it, Joan, is yours too.