February 28, 2008
Uncategorized
No Comments
By Duggan's Dew of Kirkintilloch
Reading Le Carré’s recent “The Mission Song”, and musing on moral equivalency. The poor mutt has been drifting since the evil empire popped like a balloon in the Gipper’s arthritic old mitts. He desperately lacks a new enemy, but it must be an enemy he can love, one as morally conflicted as his heroes themselves. Their conversations with foes, even the silent ones as between Smiley and Karla, are about recognizing their similarities as professionals in a lonely trade, by definition removed and isolated and elevated. Members of an exclusive and exquisitely morally troubled club.
Like Le Carré, moral relativism is ultimately snobbish. While bending over backwards to avoid classification, like the ‘bigotry of low expectations’, it really is about the exclusion of those ‘not like us’, and about stratification. Moral relativists are exam-passers, by nature authoritarian and exclusionist. Some pass, some fail. Ideological barriers are nothing to them beside the professional collegiality - and comforts - of their exam-passing, tenure-earning, essay-writing achievements. Le Carré went after big pharma in that medicine book that got made into a movie, and arms dealers in another one, I think - but there could be no dialogue with such abstract villains. It is his entire society he wishes to feel superior to, and to convey his misgivings in set-piece dialogues with the other sides’ villains. He could not personify those post-Cold War enemies and talk with them and share their doubts and misgivings. They were just big evil targets for his heroes to go around being diffident and English and rather much nicer than. (His chaps do so well at concealing their revulsion at the presence of Americans, those inconvenient and uncouth allies.)
So, moral relativism needs something to be cosily relative with - and it sure as hell can’t be militant Islam. Even Le Carré could not bring off a dialogue of his delicately sensitive Brit allusively debating a Muslim counterpart, because even Le Carré would have to concede that in such proximity to the jihadi, the Britisher would probably soon lack the tongue to talk with or indeed a head out of which to speak rot.
Reading this one is like accompanying a child on a creaky fun-house ride, knowing from the echoes ahead what soon must happen and what emotions one must share with the little one along the way. Ah well, he is a very good professional writer whose real world has grown away from him, leaving him with the interior world of a mentally narrow and emotionally stifled Englishmen politely wandering through increasingly improbable dramas.
(A little checking found this on the Penguin site. How sweetly they express his quandary of the last two decades.)
An absolutely triumphant bestseller
Absolute Friends has been hailed everywhere as the masterpiece toward which John le Carré has been building since the fall of Communism. This thrilling tale of loyalty, betrayal, and international espionage spans the lives of two friends from the riot-torn West Berlin of the 1960s to the grimy looking-glass of Cold War Europe to the present day of terrorism and uncertain new alliances alliances that aren’t always what they seem to be.‘
February 27, 2008
Uncategorized
3 Comments
By Glendronach
Canada’s 24th place political blogger decides that statistics are just lies but truth can be found in megalomania:
Here’s one of Warren’s truisms, then: legitimacy is not found in numbers. Rightness does not equate with popularity. You can be entirely, utterly alone, as Jesus Christ was in the end - as the other prophets were, like Mohamed and Moses, at key moments in their lives - and still be irrevocably right.
So how does all of this relate to web stats?
Indeed
Krikey!
UPDATE: Your correspondent commits to addressing the matter of Warren Kinsella no further, as it is clear that from here on his further debasement can only reach depths repellant to the intelligent observer and inconsequential to constructive pursuits.
February 26, 2008
ecology
1 Comment
By Dalwhinnie
Daily Tech records the following: All four major global temperature tracking outlets (Hadley, NASA’s GISS, UAH, RSS) have released updated data. All show that over the past year, global temperatures have dropped precipitously.
Meteorologist Anthony Watts compiled the results of all the sources. The total amount of cooling ranges from 0.65C up to 0.75C — a value large enough to erase nearly all the global warming recorded over the past 100 years. All in one year time. For all sources, it’s the single fastest temperature change ever recorded, either up or down.
____________________________
The ice doth come and go as it listeth, and grindeth the earth beneath its vasty weight. When Toronto is pushed by advancing ice into Chattanooga, Tennessee, will David Suzuki please admit his manifold sins and errors? I doubt it.
February 25, 2008
Culture
No Comments
By Dalwhinnie
I was thinking about the nature of the Estonian composer Arvo Part’s music the other night as I was listening to the glorious and completely perfect rendition of it by the Elora Singers under Noel Edison. I was hearing Part not as a modern composer but as someone who has gone back to the musical composition styles of Orlando Gibbons, Tallis, Monteverdi, and Palestrina, and Orthodox Church composers unknown to me. That he is a Christian composer is obvious. He is composing religious music in the style of all three Christian denominations: Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant. He says the choice of language determines for him the musical style, so that if commissioned to do something in English it sounds like a commentary on English Renaissance compositional techniques, for instance. It could be so, but I suspect he is being way too coy. I think he is deliberately going back to the idea of music as it originally was in those times: religious, devotional, and even private - not meant for more than 12 people in the audience, maybe fewer. The number of musicians required to play his music is likewise small. It is as if he has decided that the whole western musical tradition needs to start anew, with very small ensembles, and get away from the titanic emotional outpourings of the 19th century, the bizarre ideological nonsense of the mid 20th, and return music to its roots in the expressions of the soul.
Try a comparison of the Beatitudes, which ends with Petrenko’s triumphal blast from the organ, and De Profundis, in Latin. One sounds so English in style, the other so Latin. Or at least English and Latin as interpreted by some talented musicological alien. His Orthodox work in Kanon Pokajannen is equally true to that tradition.
In any case I think with Part we are in the presence of a complete reinvention and rediscovery of music, which is not trying to go forward, but to go back to its wellsprings in expressions of faith.
See if that interpretation makes any sense for you.
February 23, 2008
American Politics
1 Comment
By Arran Gold
When will Obama have his last KFC meal? That is the question that most intrigues your correspondent these days.
Read the rest…